Background
Arrayed over more than 13,000 islands and inhabited by more than
200 million people, Indonesia seems destined to exhibit an inevitable
tension between local and centralized authority. When Indonesia decentralized
its health system in 2001, district-level leaders and managers assumed
the responsibility for planning, budgeting, implementing, and monitoring
the delivery of primary health care, including essential drugs and
family planning. This shift from a centralized model of health care
delivery has made it necessary for district managers as well as central
institutions to develop new management systems and leadership practices.
In the decade before decentralization, Indonesia
was on a path toward better health and survival rates for children
under five and their mothers. Modern family planning methods had
reduced the total fertility rate. Increased immunization of pregnant
women and infants and better treatment of diarrheal diseases and
acute respiratory infections had reduced newborn deaths.
But progress has been uneven. Health surveys
in Indonesia in 2002-2003 indicated that only 51 per cent of children
under 12 months of age are fully immunized. There are many deaths
among newborns. Wide geographic and demographic disparities persist
in the survival and health of young children and new mothers. And
while access to modern family planning methods has increased, there
is still a large unmet need for contraception.
Assessments by the Management & Leadership
Program (M&L) in 2002 and 2003 suggest that the changes wrought
by decentralization, which have often led to insufficent local
budgets and gaps in oversight, have undermined the availability
and quality of family planning and other basic health services,
especially services for the poor.
Summary of Work
Since 2001, M&L has been working with managers
to address Indonesia's most urgent health challenges by strengthening
the nation's decentralized public health infrastructure. We are
providing technical assistance to the Ministry of Health (MOH)
and National Family Planning Coordinating Board (BKKBN) to ensure
the delivery of basic health services, including family planning.
This is one of M&L's most comprehensive programs, with dozens
of partners in addition to USAID.
The M&L program, which is working at the
central, provincial, and district levels of the health system,
has these key objectives:
- define and establish a legal framework for
essential public health services and functions (EPHSF), and minimum
service standards;
- build the capabilities of district and municipal
health teams to improve performance of high-priority health services,
including family planning, and strengthen district and municipal
management skills and systems;
- improve management of essential drugs by national
programs and the districts and municipalities;
- foster the use of data by district managers
to improve program performance and to advocate for public health
funding.
Results
Legal framework for
essential public health services and functions established
M&L's support helped the MOH examine health laws in other countries
and issue a Ministerial Decree (October 2003) that established
obligatory authorities, basic health services, and minimum service
standards for districts and municipalities. The BKKBN established
obligatory functions, basic services for family planning and family
welfare, and minimum service standards for districts and municipalities,
provinces, and the central structure.
Health planning teams
improve performance
Analysis of data, effective planning and budgeting, and monitoring
and evaluation of implementation are keys to improving the performance
of public health teams that manage and deliver essential health
services. M&L developed a Performance Assessment and Implementation
process, available in English and Bahasa Indonesia, which allowed
district health and municipal teams to use existing evidence and
data to assess and compare health facilities, prepare plans and
budgets for essential (obligatory) public health services, and
identify the most urgent priorities—family planning, antenatal
care, child birth management, neonatal care, immunization, TB and
malaria control.
M&L is continuing to build an infrastructure
to support the district health teams by training local facilitators
to conduct this Performance Assessment and Implementation process.
Management of essential
drugs improved
M&L technical assistance has improved the distribution of essential
drugs. The tracer drug list was refined (from 32 to 22); the list
now includes critical drugs (such as drugs for tuberculosis), vaccines,
contraceptives, and related medical- surgical commodities. M&L
developed manuals and guidelines for procurement, distribution,
warehouse management, treatment protocols, and training.
A District Level Assessment Tool (DLAT) was developed
by M&L in early 2003. It has been used to assess drug management
and availability at warehouses and health centers. Survey results
showed that 70 percent of the 22 essential drugs were available,
although stock-outs were observed for vaccines and contraceptives
at the district level. Managers are now able to use such survey
findings to formulate district plans and budgets.
District managers
use data to strengthen surveillance programs
M&L technical assistance is helping Indonesia strengthen its
disease surveillance, which had been weakened by decentralization
in many districts, according to the MOH's Infectious Disease Surveillance
Unit.
The MOH and M&L are collaborating with provincial
health offices and districts to put new epidemiology guidelines
for communicable and non-communicable diseases into practice. Surveillance
and outbreak control practices were added to the process for health
planning and budgeting. The evidence-based plans developed by the
teams in two districts led to their success in advocating for additional
funding to manage pneumonia, control TB, and promote safer childbirth.
|